One day recently, Paul Urban, who co-owns Block 16, did some math. 

For the first time in a long time — maybe ever — he noticed business at the popular downtown Omaha lunch spot slowing down. At the same time, food prices were steadily rising. Together, it felt significant enough to investigate. 

“I sat down one day, and I added up every cost, and I realized that every time we sold a Block burger, we were losing $1.24,” he said. “We’re OK, but we had to raise our prices. We had to do it just to survive.”

Urban isn’t the only one who is feeling the pressure. In the past month, several local restaurants have announced plans to close their doors for good.

Same-store sales traffic at U.S. restaurants was down by 3.3% this year through Oct. 6 versus the same period in 2023, according to a story in the Wall Street Journal. Visits to casual-dining restaurants fell 4.5% during that same period.

Diners are also paying some of the highest food prices in memory. Compared to four years ago, grocery prices are up about 20%, according to consumer price index data from the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis. And though inflation decreased in September, according to the latest consumer inflation report, it doesn’t feel that way for most people because most grocery and restaurant menu prices haven’t come back down, instead leveling off at their higher level.

Urban said the original price of a Block 16 Block burger — one of the restaurant’s signature menu items — was $8.95. In April 2022, rising food costs forced him to raise the price to $12.95. 

Restaurants aren’t raising prices to gouge customers, said Ernie Goss, a Creighton University economics professor. They’re doing it to stay in business, he said.  

He explains the resulting scenario for diners like this: 20% of the dining public is doing just fine financially and likely still can afford to eat out as before. Those individuals are probably the ones supporting Omaha’s higher-end, fine dining restaurants, he said. 

But the majority of Nebraskans — maybe those who ate out only occasionally, and often at cheaper fast casual or chain restaurants — are more acutely feeling the pain of rising prices, and are going out less or not at all.

“Individuals who have the money are getting pinched, but they still have the money to go out to eat,” he said. “It’s the lower income individuals who are really getting pinched, and they downgrade to eating at home and other, even cheaper food.”

Those are the same shoppers choosing Costco and Walmart to buy bulk groceries at competitively low prices, he said. If they do dine out, most likely they are choosing a fast food restaurant. 

Brett Geiger, who runs Izzy’s Pizza and an accompanying food truck, said even national exposure — his business was one of several local restaurants featured on the Food Network’s “Diners, Drive-ins and Dives” earlier this year — doesn’t protect a restaurant from scarily slow days when customers simply don’t show.  

Geiger turned to social media several times this fall, reminding customers of their hours and location and posting mouth-watering pizza photos in an attempt to drum up business. In September he turned to social media again, announcing that Izzy’s was pulling out of a planned new location in west Omaha. 

“People expect we have a line out the door because we were on television,” he said. “Perception and reality are just kind of two different things.” 

He said the business has seen price increases in ingredients like cheese and meat. While researching chicken wings, a potential new menu item, the cost of the meat itself was much higher than Geiger anticipated.  

“I would have had to charge like, $30 for a pound of wings, and that’s just ridiculous,” he said. “I just don’t think the public is educated in that kind of stuff. They see someone raise prices, and they think we’re just trying to make more money. It’s not about making more. It’s about staying alive.”

Ongoing supply chain challenges are one contributing factor to the higher prices restaurants pay their suppliers, Goss said. Some restaurants are responding to higher prices by serving smaller portions or changing suppliers altogether. 

Logan Barr, who runs Plum Creek Farms based in Burchard, a popular supplier for locally raised chicken, said in a post-COVID world, his business model has taken a 180-degree turn. 

“It’s been a transformation away from the restaurant business,” Barr said. 

Not long ago, 70% of Plum Creek’s business was selling whole birds to chefs at restaurants. Plum Creek became well known through high-end restaurant menus, and its name regularly appeared on chalkboards inside restaurants during the boom of the “farm-to-table movement.” 

Now, he sells primarily to grocery stores, local butchers and directly to home cooks themselves.  

“Some of it was COVID. People started cooking at home, and were more willing to buy a quality product to eat at home.”

Some restaurants that bought Plum Creek chicken have gone out of business. Others no longer have the staff required to break down whole Plum Creek birds and use all the parts in the “nose to tail” style of cooking necessary to make the higher cost worth it.

“Most of our restaurant customers now are country clubs,” he said. “Most of the time, our price points no longer fit the restaurant margins.” 

A few restaurants, including Block 16, Dante, Dirty Birds and Via Farina, still do buy Plum Creek chicken, wanting to stay committed to the local producer and the quality. But that commitment puts serious pressure on the restaurant’s profit margin and the price of menu items. 

Part of the increase in prices is related to the labor shortages – and subsequent wage increases – coming out of COVID, Goss said. 

Goss said hourly pay for restaurant workers is now often significantly above the federal minimum wage. Some restaurants use automated labor, like self-service checkout, but customers often perceive that as low-quality customer service. Even some drive-through windows are now closing because of lack of workers, he said. 

“There has been a significant sea change in the way all of us eat and shop,” Goss said. “I don’t know if we are ever going back.” 

For Urban, that sea change means moving away from some more “fine dining” style dishes when Block 16 is open on weekend evenings and focusing more on sandwiches and affordable items. Just last week, Urban posted that the restaurant’s beef prices dropped slightly. He adjusted the price of that signature Block burger accordingly, shaving a dollar off the price. It’s now $11.95. 

For the first time in years, something on the Block 16 menu – their iconic burger, in fact – became more affordable. 

“We are … literally waiting for the day we can get closer to our old prices,” he wrote. “We’re not there yet but it’s a step in the right direction. Thanks for sticking with us through all of this. Come in this week and see if the burgers taste better a lil bit cheaper!” 

The Flatwater Free Press is Nebraska’s first independent, nonprofit newsroom focused on investigations and feature stories that matter.